c& 2007

Jv mbmk=l DC lCF&
kjOv
Dc lj[kj
DhC kn Mkwk lj ku Dnl. Dck kub cnCp yjyj, Dck vn kub cnCp JF&, Dm. ku h{ J, Dp h{ `lmb` Jl vn- n lhkǮ Sk. lcU `Dp箳 h{v Jv m[u Dn` JkwJj Sko Mkwkcl&y kub k, DhC Jv mbmk=lǮ vJv iU k{u ckU nl.

 


hC Kjb Dmb Dn k ? Sk mbhC& h{v `Jv` vJ箳 Ƭu m[Ʈr ou Dn k ? (FL DCK Sk > GY jnl. ku miU h{ Jl nl k ? k llu knpC J. hC l kn FL c vn. Dm.) lj, Sk h{ omN h{k[ Jv mbmk=lǮ mboY&l DbiuvoxM kjl Dn. lcU kn > vƽl h[ll DC ci Gjb MOC ijp pCJl.
mJ&mOjChC n Dp h{ cnCp vkwk kCl ? lj 15 l pJUhm 30 J<x Jilu cu-cu DC lC cb[U n Dp h{ Dm DhC cvl. lcU Dp箳 lCF&k[ hnlv lbv mcj pJ uiCN mYJlu箳 hjmLlǮ Jj nCn DJMk Dn. 15 l 30 Jilu lCb JlJjCl Sk iǮ b[ mc Dn. l cnCp lb$%v il DC lvcv Yjll Puu you! `mbiCk` mj nT uiuvblj n h{ DC lnv cnJ cnCp `Fbjv` DH, YJ cnl ouv `cTm`j ybl mbYUCj, jpJ ibO b Myobl mbi lj, `SkJmJ Mlkk[ hnCj` n h{! Dp Jv mbmk=lǮ vJv p Dj[ Sk l Dn, l kWEyo lb$%v J cnlǮ JmHl o[u Dn.
Kjb lj mbiCk Dm EkJ Fbjv lb$%v, n ovn JvǮ cOc Dnl. DhCu lL JJ uil. Dmb ojƮ$JCJj nl vn. Jv n Sk vJ `kj` mcpCb ijpb Dn.
hmlkbk[ v JUC箳 lCb cvmklciu n Sk kjC Dm Mklb. Kjblj l kio hmlkbk[ JUl vnl, Dmb FL DhC Hj lj cnC Mkl. Dp cbyF&-hC- vMk bmjK cnvijbl Dm EkJ kCkJu, pUiJ, JlcUmjK cC Mnjbl `v`Jv cnl `[Tvu[` kjCb n lCbm Sk mnp J muY Ƭ yvu Dn.
hmlkb okvk[ cub JUl vnl, Dm Sk ElJn cnj^Yj Jj cCmbcO Jnl Dn. Kjb lj pilk hlUJj Dmb JOv kjCb O[mb vJn, lj cK&hCb ju. `n@j h@j`mjK hmlk cukv piYj hmlk-Kh Jc c[u Dnl. hC `n@j h@j` c DCK JiU Dn. lk[ DhC vblj JU; hjbl Dm `v Spm&`v mnm v YJCj J< (Dmb cnj^dz JjJblbb cnCCb!) unuu hmlkb J-mbKn cǮ Dn. Dcl& mvbb `The Argumentative Indian' n hmlk DhC IT Mk. cnCp pilk hlUJj Dm J̮jk `cu` Khl Dn.
Dhu Kj y FL Dn. cnj^l cj Y<l Dm `cu` k Khl vn, b k[b Dhuu h[ub Dn. l KhJ cnCv lCb oMv lv kv PuJjn lmo Dluh cUl, DM Sk lj Dn DC lcU `lCF& Jl vn` n Dhu `Mkwk` yvu Dn.
Dp lC Jl vnl DC lln cnj^dz lC Jl vnl, Dm cnCC kǮ Dn. kmb ? mboh Kj lC kJǮ `D<Jj yu kn` n kJlmbn b[ Khu. GonjC omjb- mbp Oj kJǮ `cPb FJubmb nml#j` kJlmbn hnu DJ= kMvvblj ov oJmbl mbhu. lmjb GonjC- `yk Mv` kobyjǮb! p Dp cnj^Yj cnJuv J*ddc cb[Ul pjoj & Dn. nhuk[ `ckxEi` J<Jju lp% Huh kuj b hmlk Yjllu DkjJ J yjJ DJ= mJ&l pml cnj^l Jku iu, Dm cOblj pnj Pu nl. n hmlk Jkl ICj ynlbM lC Dnl p cnj^Yjlu ScyS, ckxEi DC D@[Jn&EPi DM JJO DYmcb FvmmdcO Mkl Dnl.
miU GonjCbJv Sk cnJ i u#l l. l DM k, Dp h{ nukbHukb Jl DC omjb- lb kjDjM mbybOl Dmuub Jl. DhC Sk yy u#l Iu nJ. l cnCp Dm lCb YJ<M mbybOl mnl cjl Dlbl kc cCl kMl nl Dn. cj cOclv Lck M#C Iluu cubv cnJuv mljJj DM J<b mbkuhv mcpv ICb ijpb Dmlb; p lbv FbpcOv mcpv IJb uilb! Dhuk[ ckxEihmv D@[Jn&EPihl箳 Dvk JJmb JMu<C kjCj hmlkb GhuyO Dnl; hjbl lCb kvlv D@k@[ck hmlk pJUhm vnǮ Dnl DC JMu<Clck yy vblj ll- n Dp箳 lCF& DJmL Dn.
mnl箳 yylln kn yy u#l DCv oC ijp ju. Dhuk[ lCbmǮ mnl n mbkuhv DmllJl vn. lp% cb[UR cl, ov kjC Dnl. hnub `DL&`kjC Dmb k, Dhuk[ 15 l 25 Jilu cu n kcJl vnl. lcU l hmlk Jkl Ilv lb Ijlu cb[UR cKv Jj Ill. lcU vJJU lCbmǮ, lCbv Dhu Ju Dm mnl unv m kjCm uKk kjll. kjC hmlk m, kMv D|Lk yyR YJ DmCN i Dnl.
lu omjb kjC Dmb k, Dhuk[ 17J J<&hmv箳 h{u mJv `{` cvub iub. lcU `{b`mǮb mnl DC `lCb`mǮb mnl DM Ji&Jj nT Mkuu vn. `mljJb J<&` n h. Y. YJ b kL, lmb `Ku Ku hC` n jlvkj clkj b kLmbn n lCb JM mbybOl nl. ciu kn J<lu vkb GonjC m m# Dnl. `clǮ i[ kjC`, `mb k kjb ?` EkJ vklb Duub `up kb^u` n lCb YJJ Gui[v oKJCj J< Dnl; hjbl `vk` ku H@c& JiU DC hmlkb JiU, nn DhC Ovl Ilu hnp.
`kmu` kobyju nn Sk cl Dn. JM< cnCp Dp h{n `kmu` DJp&v Jl. lJj & kjl. kjC hb[jbi mbiJkj n lC lbv Dhu c$ Jl. `Dckb mJlb$` n MMbk Dk b kobyj Dp xl vn, n JjOYmn Dp箳 hjmLll hnJm cUl, n vco kjJ uiu.
Dpn Slnmk kobyN Ju pll. `mJc`, `sJ`,

Duip JC oJC
Dhu D<箳 ybo lUIj mJ& Pjk DhC GI[u nJl. Sko l GI[u k ynj jbi, mj, ibO mJ& Sk jbiv kMJu myl ITv hn mvHwmjK DbiCl hhlu.
mvu [iJkj, hvJu, EmOoi&

lhlho (kLmbn) kL- lk J. h. kU
`
hjl<kb, Mmlh$kb, kh, hu, mJC&hokb cnCp M vJn l kla! Mb vlb Jl&cvkUlu lk #CM mFlkb Dmlb. lk #C m IJ uil. M lmb DC mbmj ƬkmjK Dml. Jkmcj GYb jub k lk y@ub kn lj kjJb uilb.
`Yl, Jl&cv, YJ< cnCp lv mchmd` yum cnCp kU. kuu lk W[ kUJj mhJ vn. l lcnu D[JJ uil. m[v oCb, LbyJCb, uJCb hk kn lj Sk kjJb uilb. lcn pj y@um&SC[u Dmu lj mLojyjyj OJhU kjJ uil. Flj KUbcC yoc k n SkcJ Gh vn.`
Dbpv IJj, [WyJu

c$n! h. u. oMhb[
SKo oul cui p JU j DUR kJl unl, l JU cu l kun npj vybObh# c bl Jl. Dmb Jlb k, p IjbcOu mj njJu nl, l Ijblv mj J, l IjbcOv Jj J n kJ{ c bl Dn Dbop c c cnCCNbv km l vn. lb kjC Dmb Dn k, Dc箳k[ ku #$Jj c DmCh# DhC kuJbl Dnl cO Dmlb. Instead of loving art you love yourself in art.' p JUu cu cc hjc kjll, pJn M.Sc. u Hm&kwum ll l JUm Sk mJ$yF& Hubv, Sk ku Dijkjbv, Sk ku kkv lc箳m MJ Kuuu Dnl n Jm vk.
jp ECkj, cnc, cbyF&

jmk n! h. u. oMhb[
`ua @huv `uFc uF` cnCv Sk Ʈ$h Dn. jbiYcJju Picihmv oj Hku iuu Sk v n i Dn. l箳Jj c kjCj l c$C lu Jjl, `Dj, LSjvb lu n Dmb P[kv Hkv oub lj l lLb k[c[u plm kMu? lu I=C vn l k l vk箳 Ob?` l cnCl, `n. cu I=C l. cu pcvJj mb[uub j hnvn I=C l. hC k k, cP vmmvlvn j Jnl Dmlb.
cvnj vH[kj, vi[, hC

c km Pu? . k. D$
unv cu MUl pm jclicl pl v, lm c D<l jclicl uu Dn. Jl Hu omu, lJj kJl kj.
cu omu, lu i mbi. Gom nN cCm Yu lu nmJ. o:K m$ Yu, l箳 pJvJj vk j. yk mbvm uu, l JU kj.
ioa omu, l箳h{ JKv o. kC cnh< Yu, l ppkj kj.
SKo c& D{Uu, lbl mcu n. D<lu lk iyu cu p%m Dn. K[k GI[ omu k cbpj pm l箳l [kJl, lm pJvl [kJC cu Hj nm Dn. mj Dhuu omu hnp, mj mcpu hnp Dvd mj Du hnp, Dm cu Jl.
mOj uu, cub[

DhC mj Dp&v J. h. kU
ov jpklcO lJk clYo nll. mv GY ku pll DC l# jCbiCcO ov DvUK cCmb Skckbv cjll. lbb lj Skckl kClb Jj vmlb. Y<n Sk vml. DhC Eno DC mcj cmucv nn iU P[lv Ovl vmu. c cjub vn lj l C IF&u Flkw mO piC箳 Fslv iU mll. yU pCj pJ Sk ul-yul pJ Dn n Mvb Gvcl Puu cCmu kOǮ pCJCj vn k? IvmboY&l Sk DbiJj k DCCj GonjC Dn. omN cn箳 JUm Sk mvk Kbokl oy Ov ymu nl. M$h#lu Sk mvk nu ui v ol ci Tv GY jnu. hC l箳 hl Kbpj KhmChJa l k kjl n lu hnJmb Jub. lvb hnub lj Kbokl ymuu mvk箳 nll hlvǮ DC cuǮ H nl DC l {m{m j[l nl. l hnl#C l mvkv ybok Hkv ou. Kbokl G[ cju. KMlv mJl: yk, cu H k{u DC oIb Skckbv c cv j[ uiu.
pcv JnC, C

mjbM DC kkj
DYJǮ mJlb$ Dn, hC l Dc&o vn.
l mJlb$u mLu, ku, mYl DC mcpk hjmLl b c&o Dnl, ijHo IC lv nll DC
k箳 Yck Ilu pll.
knR cl DM kCln c&o kub DC mnl箳 DYJl DmC i vn. kjC mnlk J kuJbl n mp&vMul DLJ Jjb hJ$J< o# Dml. lcU l mJ&mcv Dbikjll l ci& vJ[l vml.
l Dhu DC DvK ci& vJ[l. lcU l箳 mnlk=l, `Jjk=l` DLJ kuk=l mcpcvu Okwk oll. vJv Jj oCN J vJm=pv kjCN cnCp vJl Dn OjCN kuJblv J mnlkv mcpu Okwk pj ou lj l hJC lko mcpk[ DmC DJMk Dn, Dm b cnCC, lj Okwklb$ pCJhJ&k Dn Ojl mcpu mnlk=lǮ J kuk=lǮ mn糳v Okwk oC n
mcpk Mbll yI[JCj Dml,
Dm omj i lJo.
k=<C H[Cm, ooj

DOlc箳 biCl h. . DjEJovL jvUkj
DhupJU mbiCmjK kn Dmu lj l omNu pj mbiJ DC omNpJU mbiCmjK kn Dmu lj l mpvv Skv IJ. Dhu Jj omNJj mv uo vl DC omNb v hCj Jj Y[hn mJl:Jj uov IT vl;
cnCp Dhu mJlb$ J hjmvcv phC n.
DhC& hjbph, [WyJu

vijk DJvM Oc&Okj
v@up Fp hJj. mKjc H onJ vhm. l iJk[b L[ Ml Dn. l J[u 7/12 GlNm luk[ iu. mKjc箳 J[ubv ov lm luv ojJpynj GYb kv Jub. n mcpuJj Dc mKjc KJUu n cnJb Dn. l Ʈ[u, mblhu, pT o, DhC k kjCj cnCv lW[ oyv ykwkwb cj mnv kjl jnu vn. l Ʈ[u. DhC Ʈ[l vnl. mml jnl. Dl pj Ʈ[u Mku nJb. llv cnJ n, k Ʈ[v mKjc luu cju iu vn. hmlkb okvl iu. c. p. c. DOvc mk Y. ob[JOv, oJC Ƭ, mbnl, Hpoj Ƭ mbnl, Dmu hmlk ITv Du. lu kUl iub k 7/12 Glj lj ov hu cUu nJ. MlkNvb l cilu k, ly[ly oCb n lub kl&J Dn. lu nn kUl iub k, DhC p lu-cmJk- h. h.- hum, F. b$Cu GiǮ Iyjl, l lj Dhu mJk Dn. Ivvmj oM cuk DhC Dnl mcv vijk.
pjc hLJ, Dku

mJhvk[v mlk[ (kuhv Ju knC) cOj MvYi
... Gp[l h=LJJj cnmij mh DUK ll. [Wijb DU KUClu Jll. JUJb mvj jbi Yuc lk[ J[Jk[ hmjuu oml. l mnj JUJb Dn. llv vU jbi J[Jk[ jI oml. Sk khM yjk Dvd ci nUnU Hil bo nCj. l Yi l pJvJnv, vF&u vo Dn. hJU mvj kioJj MF& DIU bobo nl pJ lM l oml Dn. hb{j ck Iluu [Wijjbib DU cnCp ncu hJ&l. llu SJnjm FLv mh, sm oml. lL pJU cP oM Dn, cP kv&u Dn.
njJ, hb{N, vU, hJU, kj[, uu vm|ik jbib GOUC DmCj n JiJiU lk[ Skckbl Flk hKu ymu Dnl, DM jbimbil mOl Dnl k pC k@vJnmJj c vmi&Ʈ$ yvJu Dn.
kok mUbk, Jb

lJcm: l OJ Yf (ip.) Dv. Dbpv vjkC
SK C箳 DLJ h#箳 plǮb DmllJ Okwl l Dnmb Jub, lj mjb pi l pl JJ箳 lvbv uilb. lLkLl ypJ uk DmJmL nTv Y<Cb ol EkJ uK unl mll. hm K& kjll. l plǮ Cbb DmllJ v nC v<O pnj kjll. hjbl cCmb SKo mbmk=l, lb hjbhj, lb pJv h cUhmv v nC Ok vc&C nl. lb mbhC& mcpJJmL c[v h[Cjmb Jlb, lJn l hjmLlu hjJl&v cnCv vJpub plb!
Dvu kjbyUkj, youhj

Ov l iv@k ku [@. cv vjkj
m$ cnCp c KC Dml. h< c mnp Jm Mkl. l箳Jj kuu c l mJL&m [UD[ k Mkl, hC yF& cm mJ&mJ oT Mkl. ynlk l li pvcpl mJYJ JM<cU vmi&v H yF&u vJv pJu pvc oCm m#c kub Dn J h<u l箳 mJLa, Dhhuh mJYJcU l oJ Dvbohmv JbƮl Juu Dn. kjC l yukm m$ knn kju lj nT Mkl l D<lu kCln kC k[ GljCj njkC yv Mkl, l mJjp mJhv yICj ppT nT Mkl, J cubv I[Jv lbv J[ub mcv kju hJCj ml nT Mkl. cvJv yF&u Dyu yvJu Dn, hC vmi& v l myu Dn.
cunj JjUkj, ooj

kC kuc yy Dc
c cbl cilu, mK nl Jb cnCv...
cu oj cUub, c MnCb JnJb cnCv
c mcL& cilub, cP ppkj JnJ cnCv...
c oyU Pu, F&j DJC J cnCv
c mjb kn civ Ilub, D< Yil Jb cnCv...
cu D< cUub, mjb kn Yil Jb cnCv
cilub l kO cUub vn
cUub l cUuJv jnub vn
ckw L&vbv nkj Du,
Dvd o:K cP mK m#oj Pu.
M|c pJbl, C

cP m#lkj oji DY ybi
kl uJb? kl ilv uJb? kmb uJb? k kUp IJ? bn Mm$ vc&C Pub Dn.
uCb n cvJ箳 lm u# J<祮 Flnmlu mJ&l pml kUhl uuu k=l Dmuv l vJJU unvhC Sk-o[ J<& Jl Mkuu lb$Jj m[v YiCj vn. uCb Mm$ yvJJb uiu, MkJb uiu. l Sk mJlb$ i nF&u. cu v l Dmuu mbmk=l Y<l c Mm$b `j-i` Dmb vckjC kub Dn. uCb n cvJ mbmk=lǮ kl cnJ Yi Dn, Sk Puk `j` Myohmv k k Myo J DL& vc&C Pu l hnuv cUl. j (nuCj, pbic), j (mpJ), jj, jC, jk (DOvkjl Jl kjCj), & (En[C, mbmkj, JiCk), ov&, Dj, DjC, D&. cjlu `jC` n MyooKu uC KCM kl pJU mbybO nl l oKJl. mbmk=lJju ob[iF& mchl!
ckbo myC, kua

Sk Skj JbkM c[iUkj
kn cCmb DM Dmll k, p Mnj pJvJv jcl vnl,
jvl yJjll, iocjll.
kn DM Dmll k, Mnjl jnv jvJv iocjll.
vboCb v DJ[CN m$ cCb l JjbJj cnj hUv pll.
jvbJvb JC sbo vboCb v DJ[CNbmǮ Dn.`
DMk DHU, kunhj

oJEyo Jp kk
Kj k&kl& kO pml yul vn. l ukbv Dmb kOǮ mbil vn, k n mjb c kjl DC cPcU mjb uub. kCln iǮ m=pv箳 JU Myo vnc Dyu nll. kJ, Ʈ$kj, uKk, kukj, kjij, Muhkj pJn v|cl k uil lJn l pY hC& Mbl Dml. cCm pYJj mbc cUJl lJn l箳 Dbljl Sk kj M vc&C nl DC lcU lb k& DOkOk h{ plb. k&jl Dmlv cv OjC kjCb n vmi&vc Dn. Emn MkjJj lv h[l lJn ip&v kjl vn DC ijpCj cI yjml vn, lmb YbkCj k$ Jl vn, DM cnCcO n DL& o[u Dn.
Dvbl Oj, Eo[j (vMk)

DivhbL S.h.p. Dyou kuc
...Mbk Du lj lJj cl kj. ku lj vGco Jn vn, DM J= yvl iu. Dm DlcJm Dmuu J kO kCmcj MjCil hlkjl vn. Sk M l箳cO Dml. FL kl Dn, kc Hj h[l Dn, cu kC mnk& ol vn, cP kCu koj vn, cPJj Dv nl, DM j[iC il yml vn. mjU mcmbv mcj Y[v `mcmbh#, D[LUbh# c c Dn` Dm mJl:MǮ Jo kjl oJJj Jm Jv h{ pl jnll.
D@[. cvcnv oOC, cbyF&

Sk SkjJbkM c[iUkj
lk P[ n Dk<&k Dmb Sk JmlMuh Dmlb. MJ l mll nul, J{l, HUl, Hul Dmlb.
DMk DHU, kunhj

J[ub mJm Mj< h
cP yyll cu Dmb vnc Jl Dub k, pC c cu DhCnv vlǮ mJOv kub DC l D<l pLb pLb pmb hJu, p oF&u l mN c Glmklv DC
mJilMulvb mJkj ku Dn. D<l p Yi cUu l hlkv llv pJv DL& MO n cP mJYJ Dn. c u{T J=Ǯ vn. cP mJYJ Mbl mbMOkmjK Dn. mh[uu Jml Guv l箳lub cc& n[kb
DM cP J= Dn. p h{l F&u lu mcpv Ib n c D<l nUnU Mkl iu Dn. `p p Y Yl, l l cvp YiJbl...`
Jcv YomF&, Jjj

mcO mOv Dc
cP cl mJ, kC, , o, Y, mHla, jC DC JL Myob Jhj h<Ji& c DYcvv kjl Dmu lj n Myo m$Eui DmucU l m$Ǯ k=lOc& lk Dnl. lj m$bv n Dhu mJOc& phmu hnp. cnCp h<bv lyyll yHkj DmJ Dm DL& vn. lj hC m$bv kJU mJkby箳 kbhCl moJ D[kv v h[l mJv ybOc kv l Hj GOUC mcp kC ku hnp. o:KM DC JovM vl cnCp cCmk DM cP Dn.
cOj cpcoj, vMk

kv kjOv
Dvk m#h Jk p Jub llu mY<lb, Jj, Glj b vWo kv Jll. kO Jj mQo&m.kO Y< mQo&m. kO ovnm. lyyll cj mnllu cbl Joll Dn. Dm Gcc Jj, mY<lb, Glj DhC Dc箳k[ hJ Dnl. lmyl hmlkb vJ, uKkb vJ b GuuK DmCb DJMk Dn.
kun Jj n pmll pml on DUl cJCj DmJ.
Hj c Jj kln biu Dmu lj Jjl Il Cj vnl.
kjC pmll pml Jkbv mojl mLv cUJb, DC pmll pml Jv-Jj mcku pkl.
Jv-JjOvlv kCun SKo hmlk hC& JJm ku, kbk mnl mijlu ku hmlk JJl, yu ci&oM&vn nT Mku.
lJn Dm Jj-cl lj Dmlu lj Gc.
vmlu lj cc hmlkb J, Jj-cl vJ[ DC lj箳 hʳJj hJ.
vJ[k, Jk, JOk Jj-clbv `lj`l m ou pF&u.